2024 Industrial Digital Ecosystem Summit Agenda

Agenda Topic

Speaker

Description

Welcome from the organizers

Serm Kulvatunyou (NIST) and Farhad Ameri (ASU)

Welcome and logistics info from the organizers

Welcome from the host

Binil Starly (Director and Professor, ASU’s School of Manufacturing Systems and Networks)

Opening remarks

Jim Wilson (OAGi President and CEO)

Introduce OAGi and OAGi IOF/Connect memberships and their organizational missions. Updates on the organizational changes.

IOF for Digital Thread Tutorial

Organizers: Dusan Sormaz (Ohio University)

Presentations: Slides | Handout

Synopsis: This tutorial will walk the participants through how to use IOF ontology constructs to capture information about digital artifacts and physical artifacts (information about physical product, process, and their relationships). Participants will create individuals and properties based on provided example data about requirement, design, plan, simulation/digital twin model, as-manufactured product, as-used product, as-maintained product, etc. Example reasoning and queries may also be exercised.

Material Science and Engineering (MSE) Tutorial

Organizers: Alexandru Tudor (DIN Software), Thomas Hanke (Fraunhofer), Shengyen Li (NIST)

Synopsis: The organizers will lead you through a hands-on use case on using the MSE ontology for material characterization. Time permitted, linking material characterization to process improvements such as in additive manufacturing may be introduced.

Application Ontology Development and Deployment Tutorial

Organizers: Stephen Kahmann (Crown Point Technologies)

Synopsis: This tutorial will provide a hands-on experience for extending an IOF reference ontology to solve an application-specific use case. Steps include defining the use case objectives, evaluating support within existing IOF ontologies, developing an application ontology extension, mapping data into a knowledge graph, and visualizing the results.

IOF Maintenance Ontology Tutorial

Organizers: Melinda Hodkiewicz (University of Western Australia)

Synopsis: Example maintenance use cases will be outlined. Attendees will be instantiating IOF Maintenance Reference Ontology based on the example use cases and build queries. Melinda will provide a brief overview of the development process used by the Maintenance team, run through an OWLREADY process to build and add data to the ontology and run a query and finally run through an NLP to KG pipeline to extract entities and relations from unstructured engineering texts at scale using LLM.

Tutorial resources

IOF Core Tutorial
Organizers: Milos Drobnjakovic (NIST) and Arkopaul Sarkar (ENIT)

Synopsis: Hands-on tutorial about how to download IOF ontologies, instantiate ontology with data, specific use case that use Allen Algebra will be used. Time permitted, this tutorial will also include exercise for using IOF value expression and QUDT, reasoning, and SPARQL.

Enterprise Integration with OAGi Connect Tutorial

Organizers: Scott Nieman (Land O'Lakes) and Michael Figura (OAGi)

Presentations: Scott

Synopsis: This tutorial will show participants how the OAGi connectSpec standard, along with the connectCenter management software, can revolutionize the speed and agility of modern enterprise integration projects. We’ll walk through a real-world project with multiple team members, beginning with the problem definition, requirements gathering and analysis phases, and show hand-offs of real work between team members. We’ll cycle through the various project stages from analysis and development to testing and production approval. We’ll version control our assets, and show how minimal coding is required in a code-gen world. This presentation will show the future of now. Don’t miss it!

BFO Q&A Session

Organizers: Barry Smith (NCOR) and John Beverley (NCOR)

Synopsis: We will provide some general ontology modelling guidance, and provide an update on recent developments concerning BFO, including progress on the physics and math ontologies.

Slido link for posting questions

NSF Supply Chain Open Knowledge Network

Organizers: Farhad Ameri (Arizona State University) and Hyunwoong Ko (Arizona State University)

Synopsis: In this session, an overview of NSF funded Open Knowledge Network (OKN) for manufacturing supply chain will be given. We will be collecting feedbacks from industry participants and outline our plan to develop such an open knowledge network.

Biopharmaceutical Use Cases

Organizers: Roger Hart (NIIMBL)

Synopsis: In this session, the result of use case survey will be presented. Discussion to arrive at a common understanding and priority of those use cases will be conducted.

Slido link for live poll

Keynote

• Roger Hart (NIIMBL)

Biopharmaceutical Big Data program roadmap and the importance plan and role of ontology

IOF Core Working Group Update

• Milos Drobnjakovic (NIST)

• Arkopal Sarkar (ENIT)

• Jim Logan (Dassault Systèmes)

Overview of achievements, current works, future needs and then discussion topics to happen in the Working Group session

IOF Material Science and Engineering Working Group Update

• Alexandru Todor (DIN Software)

Overview of achievements, current works, and future needs.

IOF Product Service System Working Group Update

• Ana Correia (ATB)

Overview of achievements, current works, and future needs.

IOF Architecture TG update

• Jim Logan (Dassault Systèmes)

Report on recent outputs from the IOF Architecture Task Group (TG), current major working items, and the outlook.

IOF Supply Chain Working Group Update

• Farhad Ameri (Arizona State University)

Overview of achievements, current works, future needs and then discussion topics to happen in the Working Group session

IOF Maintenance Working Group Update

• Melinda Hodkiewicz (University of Western Australia)

Overview of achievements, current works, and future needs.

IOF System Engineering Working Group Update

• Jinzhi Lu (Beihang Univ)

• Jim Logan (Dassault Systèmes)

Overview of achievements, current works, future needs and then discussion topics to happen in the Working Group session

Keynote

• Andrew Eichenbuam (BioMADE)

BioMADE and the digital Backbone long term view

IOF Production Planning Scheduling Working Group Update

• Dusan Sormaz (Ohio University)

Overview of achievements, current works, future needs and then discussion topics to happen in the Working Group session

Additive Manufacturing Ontology

• Alex KItt (EWI)

Overview of the Additive Manufacturing (AM) Common Data Model and the motivation/possibility to create an AM ontology within the IOF ontology suite.

OntoCommons Update

• Arkopaul Sarkar (ENIT)

• Hedi Karray (ENIT)

Overall update from OntoCommons

Keynote

• Ryan Riccucci (U.S. Customs and Border Patrol)

Department of Homeland Security and Custom Border Protection ontology initiative.

Panel session: Ontology Standard vs. Data Exchange Standard, Friend or Foe and a Road to Coexistence or Transition

Serm’s Slides | Arko’s Slides

Moderators

• Jim Wilson (OAGi)

• Serm Kulvatunyou (NIST)

Panelists

• Scott Nieman (Land O’Lakes)

• Ryan Riccucci (U.S. Customs and Border Patrol)

• Arkopaul Sarkar (ENIT)

• Stephen Kahman (Crown Point Technologies)

• Andrew Eichenbuam (BioMADE)

• Roger Hart (NIIMBL)

Providing thought and moderate discussion on the relationships and roles of traditional messaging standard (such as OAGi Connect) and the ontological standard (such as IOF)

BFO Update

• Barry Smith (NCOR)

Will deal with early history of IOF, relation to BFO, use by industry, and with the future of IOF. Above all: how can IOF deal with those parts of industry which deal with manufacturing software?

Supply Chain Working Group Meeting

• Farhad Ameri (Arizona State University)

• Barry Smith (NCOR)

• Ryan Riccucci (U.S. Customs and Border Patrol)

Agenda

Ontology for Additive Manufacturing (Yan Lu - NIST)

Agenda

IOF Architecture TG Working Session Part 1

• Evan Wallace (NIST)

• Jim Logan (Dassault Systèmes)

Agenda | Slides

System Engineering Working Group Meeting

• Jinzhi Lu (Beihang University)

• Jim Logan (Dassault Systèmes)

Agenda

Ontology Development and Deployment Toolkit

• Stephen Kahmann (Crown Point Technologies)

• Adlane Rebai (Merck MilliporeSigma)

Agenda | Slides | Wrap-Up Session Video | Session result

Core Working Group Meeting

• Milos Drobnjakovic (NIST)

• Arkopaul Sarkar (ENIT)

• Jim Logan (Dassault Systèmes)

Agenda | Slides

OAGI Connect Meeting Part 1

• Jim Wilson (OAGi)

• Serm Kulvatunyou (NIST)

Agenda

Production Planning and Scheduling (PPS) Working Group Meeting

• Dusan Sormaz (Ohio University)

• Bill Mandrick (Raytheon)

Agenda

IOF Architecture TG Working Session Part 2

• Evan Wallace (NIST)

• Jim Logan (Dassault Systèmes)

Agenda

Opening and Welcoming

• Jim Wilson (OAGi)

Give opening remarks. Provide OAGi Connect organizational updates, achievement milestones, and future outlook.

Standards-based semantic interoperability roadmap

• Serm Kulvatunyou (NIST)

Present summary from the last meeting at Lands O' Lake (LOL).

Challenges in bioindustrial manufacturing supply chain integration

• Andrew Eichenbaum (BioMADE)

A presentation about bioindustrial supply chain data exchange will be given. Initial use case and sequence diagram will be produced at the end of the session.

Managing a Complex Supply Chain using E2E Digitalization Solutions

• Stephen Wing (Merck MilliporeSigma)

This presentation will highlight some of the key supply chain challenges facing the Biopharmaceutical Industry, and some of the current and future opportunities to improve and optimize these processes using electronic data (eData) sharing. It will also include some real-world examples and use cases to illustrate the benefits and future potential.

Metadata discussion

• Scott Nieman (Land O’Lakes)

Metadata design pattern

Requirement scenarios for managing or deploying multiple standards

• Scott Nieman (Land O’Lakes)

• Joshua Ki (Lockheed Martin)

• Elena Jelisic (NIST)

Draft formalization of material states

• Arkopaul Sarkar (ENIT)

Presentation of the proposed formalization of material state and state transitions supported by a set of use case scenarios.

Preliminary demonstration of process model to IOF ontology correspondence

• Arkopaul Sarkar (ENIT)

• Milos Drobnjakovic (NIST)

• Jim Logan (Dassault Systèmes)

Replicate an activity diagram with IOF ontologies and demonstrate the correspondence of the ontological representation to the activity diagram.

IOF Core Ontology roadmap

Brief recap of the completed and ongoing work followed by a working, interactive session that will determine the development priorities and outline the development timeline.

AM CDM development

• Kareem Aggour (General Electric)

The objective of the session is to bring AM ontology researchers and practitioners to share their ontology development experiences and use cases and pursue collaborative opportunities to develop ontological model to advance AM technology and accelerate the use of ontology in AM industry.

CDM for Data integration and exchange, use cases

• Shengyen (NIST)

AM Ontology for design

• Hyunwoong Ko (Arizona State University)

AM ontology for qualification

• Gareth Tear (Synbiosys)

Ontology network-based in-situ sensor selection for AM quality management in metal additive manufacturing

• Byeong-Min Roh (Oklahoma University)

Open Discussion

• Alex Kitt (EWI)

Introduction to systems engineering ontology

• Jim Logan (Dassault Systèmes)

• Jinzhi Lu (Beihang University)

The role of ontology in semantic-MBSE and its applications

• Xiaochen Zheng

Towards a Digital Engineering Factory for Students

• Joe Gregory (University of Arizona)

Discussion about IOF SE ontology

• Jim Logan (Dassault Systèmes)

This is a working session. During this session, moderators will discuss a future starter toolkit for the suite of IOF ontologies. It aims to assists end users in getting started with contributing to and understanding how to use the ontologies. The session's objective is to gather user requirements, define functionalities, and outline the next steps for execution. Slides | Wrap-Up Session Video

• Stephen Kahmann (Crown Point Technologies)

• Adlane Rebai (MilliporeSigma)

Introduction to CISA and IDT

• Ryan Riccucci (U.S. Customs and Border Patrol)

• Barry Smith (NCOR)

Introduction to IOF SCRO

• Farhad Ameri (Arizona State University)

SCRO & IDT collaboration

• Ryan Riccucci (U.S. Customs and Boarder Patrol)

• Farhad Ameri (Arizona State University)

Raytheon Use Cases

• Bill Mandrick (Raytheon)

Ontology of future entities and digital artifacts

• Dusan Sormaz (Ohio University)

Ontologizing various types of models and specifications such that their correspondence to reality as well as implicit connections are captured. Representing models and specifications - the challenges of OWL modeling with abstract entities

Theory of Planning

• Arkopaul Sarkar (ENIT)

PPS WG ontology roadmap

• Dusan Sormaz (Ohio University)

Discussion

Topics: Digital artifacts, Information Content Entities, Relationships between Record, Requirement, Specification, Order, Status, Roadmap

Notions of Requirement and Specification are already in IOF Core. There is a proposal for Record from Maintenance Working Group. Other typical information entities are Order and Status. What are relationships between these entities. Is Record just has other ICEs as part? Expected outcome is a refine roadmap for the PPS WG.

Reasoner

• Melinda Hodkiewicz (University of Western Australia)

• Johan Kluwer (DNV)

Problem:

• As we start to deal with industry data sets, we are going to need reasoners that can handle reasoning as data scales.

• Where is the ‘parallel reasoner’?

• There has been no new reasoning software of any significance for almost a decade.

• Hermit was last updated in 2017 and there is limited ongoing maintenance and support.

• We are not seeing any benefits from developments in IT/LLM in the reasoner space.

• There have been new developments such as RDFox, and while this is welcome and does many things well, it does not derive equivalences between classes which is important to identify duplication (e.g. in industry catalogs).

Paper that substantiates some of the above.

Discussion: Is this an area that IOF-IDO-NIST-EU-KGA and others can collaborate on?

Ontological Development Process

• Evan Wallace (NIST)

Tour of the proposed IOF ontology development process and tools.

Versioning, IRI, Deprecation

• Evan Wallace (NIST)

• Adlane Rebai (Merck MilliporeSigma)

Deprecation and moving refactoring. Introduce semantic versioning? How to use IRI subtopic? Industry Council IRI?

Development, implementation, and testing tools

• Stephen Kahmann (Crown Point Technologies)

• Adlance Rebai (Merck MilliporeSigma)

Summary from the Toolkit working session earlier in the day and may be call for a new TG and participation.

Wrap-Up Session Video

Open

• Evan Wallace (NIST)

connectCenter roadmap

• Hakju Oh (NIST)

• Scott Nieman (Land O’Lakes)

• Elena Jelisic (NIST)

Core Component, BIE, Open API, Mapping, Business Term, Distributed Standard Dev discussion

Relationship between connectSpec and IOF Ontology

• Jim Wilson (OAGi)

• Serm (NIST)

Further discussion from the previous day on this topic. Identify whitepaper direction.

Wrap up

• Jim Wilson (OAGi)