2024 Industrial Digital Ecosystem Summit Agenda

Date: Feb 6-9, 2024

Location: Memorial Union Center at Arizona State University, 301 E Orange St., Tempe, AZ 85281.

Organizers: Serm Kulvatunyou (NIST), Farhad Ameri (ASU), Jim Logan (Dassault), Bill Mandrick (Raytheon), Barry Smith (NCOR), Jim Wilson (OAGi), Dusan Sormaz (OU), Milos Drobnjakovic (NIST)

Contacts: Serm Kulvatunyou about agenda, all other matters OAGi Member Services

Registration: Registration Page. Parking can be validated by ASU.

 

Day 1: Tutorials and Working Sessions (9AM-5:30PM)

For tutorials, participants are expected to have their own laptop to do hands-on exercises. Protege, Mobi, or other applications may be used depending on the instructor.

Opening Plenary

Start Time

Length

Agenda Item

Room

Instructor/Speaker

Description

9:00

10 min

Welcoming from the organizers

Plenary

Serm Kulvatunyou (NIST) and Farhad Ameri (ASU)

Welcoming from the organizers

9:10

30 min

Opening Remark

Plenary

Jim Wilson

Introduce OAGi and OAGi IOF/Connect memberships and their organizational missions. Updates on the organizational changes (e.g., maybe we’ll have new boards and members by that time), etc.

9:40

20 mins

Break

 

 

 

Tutorial and Working Sessions

Room: Breakout 1

Room: Breakout 2

Room: Breakout 3

Room: Breakout 1

Room: Breakout 2

Room: Breakout 3

IOF Core Tutorial: 10:00-12:00
Organizers: Milos Drobnjakovic (NIST) and Arkopaul Sarkar (ENIT)

Synopsis: Hands-on tutorial about how to download IOF ontologies, instantiate ontology with data, specific use case that use Allen Algebra will be used. Time permitted, this tutorial will also include exercise for using IOF value expression and QUDT, reasoning, and SPARQL.

Material Science and Engineering (MSE) Tutorial: 10:00-12:00

Organizers: Alexandru Tudor (DIN Software), Thomas Hanke (Fraunhofer), Shengyen Li (NIST)

Synopsis: The organizers will lead you through a hands-on use case on using the MSE ontology for material characterization. Time permitted, linking material characterization to process improvements such as in additive manufacturing may be introduced.

NSF Supply Chain Open Knowledge Network: 10:00-12:00

Organizers: Farhad Ameri (ASU), Hyunwoong Ko (ASU)

Synopsis: In this session, an overview of NSF funded Open Knowledge Network (OKN) for manufacturing supply chain will be given. We will be collecting feedbacks from industry participants and outline our plan to develop such an open knowledge network.

IOF Maintenance Ontology Tutorial: 13:00-15:00

Organizers: Melinda Hodkiewicz (UWA)

Synopsis: Example maintenance use cases will be outlined. Attendees will be instantiating IOF Maintenance Reference Ontology based on the example use cases and build queries.

IOF for Digital Thread Tutorial: 13:00-15:00

Organizers: Dusan Sormaz (Ohio University)

Synopsis: This tutorial will walk the participants through how to use IOF ontology constructs to capture information about digital artifacts and physical artifacts (information about physical product, process, and their relationships. Participants will create individuals and properties based on provided example data about requirement, design, plan, simulation/digital twin model, as-manufactured product, as-used product, as-maintained product, etc. Example reasoning and queries may also be exercised.

Enterprise Integration with OAGi Connect Tutorial: 13:00-15:00

Organizers: Scott Nieman (Land’O Lakes), Michael Figura (OAGi)

Synopsis: This tutorial will introduce the participants to the OAGi ConnectSpec standard and the associated OAGi ConnectCenter tool. An example enterprise business process will be presented. Then participants will be using the ConnectCenter tool to search for standard components/messages and derive implementation specifications from them to finally generate JSON Schema and Open API document. The tutorial may also include loading the Open API document into middleware tool to develop an application connector.

Break: 15:00-15:30

BFO Update & Q&A Session: 15:30-17:30

Organizers: Barry & John Beverley (NCOR)

Synopsis: Update about BFO such as to support for the software notion will be provided. Progresses on related top-level ontology works such as physics and math ontologies will be given. A Slido link will be provided before the summit so that attendees can submit questions before the session and the organizers can prepare to answer and discuss.

Application Ontology Development and Deployment Tutorial: 15:30-17:30

Organizers: Stephen Kahman (CrownPoint Technologies)

Synopsis: This tutorial is about specializing IOF ontology for data ingestion.

Biopharmaceutical Use Cases: 15:30-17:30

Organizers: Roger Hart (NIIMBL)

Synopsis: In this session, the result of use case survey will be presented. Discussion to arrive at a common understanding and priority of those use cases will be conducted.

 

Day 2: IOF Plenary (9AM-5:30PM)

Start Time

Length

Agenda Item

Speaker

Description

Start Time

Length

Agenda Item

Speaker

Description

9:00

40 mins

Keynote talk

Roger Hart (NIIMBL)

Biopharmaceutical Big Data program roadmap and the importance plan and role of ontology

9:40

45 mins

Keynote talk

Ryan Riccucci (CBP)

Department of Homeland Security and Custom Border Protection ontology initiative.

10:25

20 mins

Break

 

 

10:45

30 mins

IOF Core WG Update

Milos Drobnjakovic (NIST), Arkopal Sarkar (ENIT), Jim Logan (Dassault Systèmes)

Give short overview of current work and needs and then invite people to get into more detail and discussion in the WG session

11:15

20 mins

IOF Material Science and Engineering WG Update

Alexandru Todor (DIN Software)

Give short overview of current work and needs and then invite people to get into more detail and discussion in the WG session

11:35

45 mins

IOF Ontology Development Lifecycle and Publication Process & IOF Architecture TG update

Will Sobel

IOF ontology development workflow and versioning. Introduce IOF Annotation Guide and IRI specification. Give update on IOF Architecture TG future work items. Invite attendees to join the working session on the next day.

Introduce IOF ontology development infrastructure tools and the viewer. Talk about potential future works.

12:20

60 mins

Lunch

 

 

13:20

20 min

IOF Supply Chain WG Update

Farhad Ameri (ASU)

Give short overview of current work and needs and then invite people to get into more detail and discussion in the WG session

13:40

20 mins

IOF Maintenance WG Update

Melinda Hodkiewicz (UWA)

Give short overview of current work and needs and then invite people to get into more detail and discussion in the WG session

14:00

20 mins

IOF Material Science and Engineering WG Update

Alexandru Todor (DIN Software)

Give short overview of current work and needs and then invite people to get into more detail and discussion in the WG session

14:20

20 mins

IOF System Engineering WG Update

Jinzhi Lu (Beihang Univ))/Jim Logan (Dassault)

Give short overview of current work and needs and then invite people to get into more detail and discussion in the WG session

14:40

20 mins

IOF Product Service System WG Update

Ana Correia (ATB)

 

Give short overview of current work and needs and then invite people to get into more detail and discussion in the WG session

15:00

20 mins

IOF Production Planning Scheduling WG Update

Dusan Sormaz (Ohio Univ)

Give short overview of current work and needs and then invite people to get into more detail and discussion in the poster and breakout session

15:20

20 mins

IOF MTConnect WG

Will Sobel

The MTConnect WG is restarting after a long hiatus. Its primary concerns are the engineered systems (devices), their parts, their capabilities, and what they can observe about themselves. We will use the MTConnect Standard’s SysML information model to understand the terms and use the behavior models' requirements to build use cases for everything from machine availability to digital twins. IOF brings another dimension to the MTConnect Standard, allowing us to reason about a machine’s capability and solve problems such as material traceability and collaboration.

15:40

20 mins

Break

 

 

16:00

20 mins

OntoCommons Update

Arkopaul Sarkar /Hedi Karray (ENIT)

Overall update from OntoCommons

16:20

40 mins

Relationships between messaging/transactional data standard and ontological/graph data standard

Jim Wilson (OAGi), Serm Kulvatunyou (NIST), Scott Nieman (Lands’ O Lake)

Providing thought and moderate discussion on the relationships and roles of traditional messaging standard (such as OAGi Connect) and the ontological standard (such as IOF)

17:00

40 mins

BFO Update

Barry Smith (NCOR)

Update on physics ontology, math ontology, BFO support for software side of things. Provide summary from the BFO session on Day 1.

18:00

90 mins

Banquet

 

 

Day 3: “IOF Working Sessions” and “OAGi Connect Meeting Part 1” (9AM-5:30PM)

OAGI Connect Meeting Part 1 (Jim Wilson, Serm Kulvatunyou)

Ontology for Additive Manufacturing (Yan Lu - NIST)

Core WG Meeting (Milos, Arko, Jim Logan)

OAGI Connect Meeting Part 1 (Jim Wilson, Serm Kulvatunyou)

Ontology for Additive Manufacturing (Yan Lu - NIST)

Core WG Meeting (Milos, Arko, Jim Logan)

Start

Length

Agenda

Start

Length

Agenda

Start

Length

Agenda

9:00

2 hrs

9:00

2 hrs

9:00

2 hrs

Coffee Break at 11:00-11:20AM

OAGI Connect Meeting Part 1 (continued) (Jim Wilson, Serm Kulvatunyou)

System Engineering WG Meeting (Jinzhi Lu, Jim Logan)

Ontology Development and Deployment Toolkit (Stephen Kahman, Adlane Rebai)

Start

Length

Agenda

Start

Length

Agenda

Start

Length

Agenda

11:20

70 mins

11:20

70 mins

11:20

70 mins

Lunch 13:00 - 14:00

Supply Chain WG Meeting (Farhad Ameri, Barry Smith, Ryan Riccucci )

Production Planning and Scheduling & Information Content Entity Working Meeting (Dusan Sormaz, Bill Mandrick)

IOF Architecture TG (Will Sobel)

Start

Length

Agenda

Start

Length

Agenda

Start

Length

Agenda

14:00

3-4 hrs

14:00

3 hrs

14:00

3-4 hrs

Day 4: OAGi Connect Meeting Part 2 (9AM-12:30PM)

OAGI Connect Meeting Part 2 (Jim Wilson, Serm Kulvatunyou)

OAGI Connect Meeting Part 2 (Jim Wilson, Serm Kulvatunyou)

Start

Length

Agenda Item

Speaker/Moderator

Description

9:00

3 hrs

ConnectCenter roadmap

Hakju Oh (NIST), Scott Nieman (LOL), Elena Jelisic (NIST)

Core Component, BIE, Open API, Mapping, Business Term, Distributed Standard Dev discussion

12:00

30 mins

Wrap up

Jim Wilson (OAGi)

 

 

Detailed Agendas of Day 3

OAGi Connect Meeting Part 1 Agenda

OAGI Connect Meeting Part 1 (Jim Wilson, Serm Kulvatunyou)

OAGI Connect Meeting Part 1 (Jim Wilson, Serm Kulvatunyou)

Start

Length

Agenda Item

Speaker/Moderator

Description

9:00

30 mins

Opening and Welcoming

Jim Wilson (OAGi President and CEO)

Give opening remarks. Provide OAGi Connect organizational updates, achievement milestones, and future outlook.

9:30

30 mins

Standards-based semantic interoperability roadmap

Serm Kulvatunyou (NIST)

Present summary from the last meeting at Lands O' Lake (LOL).

10:00

40 mins

Challenges in bioindustrial manufacturing supply chain integration

 

Andrew Eichenbaum, BioMADE

 

A presentation about bioindustrial supply chain data exchange will be given. Initial use case and sequence diagram will be produced at the end of the session.

10:40

30

Challenges in biopharmaceutical supply chain integration

Stephen Wing (MilliporeSigma)

 

11:10

20 mins

Break

 

 

11:30

30 mins

Relationship between ConnectSpec and IOF Ontology

Jim Wilson, Serm Kulvatunyou, Scott

Further discussion from the previous day on this topic. Identify action items.

12:00

60 mins

Requirement scenarios for managing or deploying multiple standards

Scott Nieman (LOL), Joshua Ki (LM), Elena Jelisic (NIST)

 

Core WG Meeting Agenda

Core WG Meeting (Milos, Arko, Jim Logan)

Core WG Meeting (Milos, Arko, Jim Logan)

Start

Length

Agenda Item

Speaker/Moderator

Description

9:00

30 mins

Draft formalization of material states

Arkopaul Sarkar

Presentation of the proposed formalization of material state and state transitions supported by a set of use case scenarios.

9:30

40 mins

Preliminary demonstration of process model to IOF ontology correspondence

Arkopaul Sarkar, Milos Drobnjakovic, Jim Logan

Replicate an activity diagram with IOF ontologies and demonstrate the correspondence of the ontological representation to the activity diagram.

10:10

50 mins

IOF Core Ontology roadmap

Milos Drobnjakovic, Arkopaul Sarkar, Jim Logan

Brief recap of the completed and ongoing work followed by a working, interactive session that will determine the development priorities and outline the development timeline.

Ontology for Additive Manufacturing Agenda

Ontology for Additive Manufacturing (Yan Lu, Alex Kitt and Kareem Aggour)

Ontology for Additive Manufacturing (Yan Lu, Alex Kitt and Kareem Aggour)

Start

Length

Agenda Item

Speaker/Moderator

Description

9:00

15 mins

AM CDM development

Kareem Aggour (GE)

The objective of the session is to bring AM ontology researchers and practitioners to share their ontology development experiences and use cases and pursue collaborative opportunities to develop ontological model to advance AM technology and accelerate the use of ontology in AM industry.

9:15

15 mins

CDM for Data integration and exchange, use cases

Shengyen (NIST)

9:30

15 mins

AM Ontology for design

Hyunwoong Ko (ASU)

9:45

15 mins

AM ontology for qualification

Gareth tear (Synbiosys)

10:00

15 mins

Ontology network-based in-situ sensor selection for AM quality management in metal additive manufacturing

BM Roh (Oklahoma State University)

10:15

45 mins

Open Discussion

Alex Kitt, EWI

SE WG Meeting Agenda

System Engineering WG Meeting (Jinzhi Lu, Jim Logan)

 

System Engineering WG Meeting (Jinzhi Lu, Jim Logan)

 

Start

Length

Agenda Item

Speaker/Moderator

Description

 

11:20

10

Introduction to systems engineering ontology

James Logan and Jinzhi Lu

 

 

11:35

15

TBA

Elaheh Maleki (European Space Agency)

Will send invitation to the speaker

 

11:50

15

TBA

Joe Gregory (University of Arizona)

Will send invitation to the speaker

 

12:05

15

TBA

Dr. Xiaochen Zheng

Will send invitation to the speaker

 

12:20

15

TBA

Dr.Michael Halvorson

 

 

Ontology Development and Deployment Toolkit Agenda

Ontology Development and Deployment Toolkit (Stephen Kahman, Adlane Rebai)

Ontology Development and Deployment Toolkit (Stephen Kahman, Adlane Rebai)

Start

Length

Agenda Item

Moderator

11:20

70 mins

This is a working session. Session moderator will lead discussion with attendees about toolkit functionalities and documentations that would make IOF ontology developer’s life easier and that would also make IOF ontology adoption more straightforward. The group will plan to come out with a roadmap.

Stephen Kahman (CrownPoint Technologies)

Adlane Rebai (Millipore Sigman)

Supply Chain WG Meeting Agenda

Supply Chain WG Meeting (Farhad Ameri, Barry Smith, Ryan Riccucci)

Supply Chain WG Meeting (Farhad Ameri, Barry Smith, Ryan Riccucci)

Start

Length

Agenda Item

Speaker/Moderator

Description

14:00

40 mins

Introduction to CISA and IDT

Ryan Riccucci and Barry Smith

 

14:40

40 mins

Introduction to IOF SCRO

Farhad Ameri

 

15:20

20 mins

Break

 

 

15:40

60 mins

SCRO & IDT collaboration

Ryan and Farhad

Discuss use cases and find intersections.

PPS and ICE Meeting Agenda

Production Planning and Scheduling & Information Content Entity Working Meeting (Dusan Sormaz, Bill Mandrick)

Production Planning and Scheduling & Information Content Entity Working Meeting (Dusan Sormaz, Bill Mandrick)

Start

Length

Agenda Item

Speaker/Moderator

Description

14:00

30 mins

Raytheon Use Cases

Bill Mandrick

 

14:30

30 mins

PPS ontology roadmap

Dusan Sormaz

 

15:00

30 mins

Representing models and specifications - the challenges of OWL modelling with abstract entities

 

Ontologizing various types of models and specifications such that their correspondence to reality as well as implicit connections are captured.

15:30

20 mins

Break

 

 

15:50

70 mins

Relationships between Record, Requirement, Specification, Order, Status

TBA

Notions of Requirement and Specification are already in IOF Core. There is a proposal for Record from Maintenance WG. Other typical information entities are Order and Status. What are relationships between these entities. Is Record just has other ICEs as part?

IOF Architecture TG Meeting Agenda

IOF Architecture TG Meeting (Will Sobel)

IOF Architecture TG Meeting (Will Sobel)

Start

Length

Agenda Item

Moderator

Description

14:00

60 mins

Use of external ontologies

Will Sobel

Rules and strategies for the incorporation of foreign ontologies. The discussion will review the normative document regarding the business and legal constraints and then work through different technical strategies based on specific use cases.

15:00

40 mins

Ontological Development Process

Will Sobel

The discussion will go into detail about the steps necessary to develop and release normative ontologies including use cases, competency questions, and ontology development. We will also cover the necessary roles required and engagement of domain experts.

15:40

20 mins

Break

 

 

16:00

45 mins

Versioning

Will Sobel

 

16:45

45 mins

Development, implementation, and testing tools

Stephen Kahman (CrownPointe Technologies)