NIST National Cybersecurity Center of Excellence (NCCoE) [map]
9700 Great Seneca Hwy, Rockville, MD 20850
Contacts
Agenda inquiries:Serm Kulvatunyou
All other inquiries: OAGi Member Services
Organizers
Serm Kulvatunyou (NIST), Farhad Ameri (Arizona State University), Jim Wilson (OAGi), Jim Logan (OAGi IOF / Ontogenesis), Barry Smith (NCOR), Michael Figura (OAGi), Jim Wilson (OAGi IOF), Dusan Sormaz (Ohio University), Milos Drobnjakovic (NIST), Arkopaul Sarkar (NIST), Alexandru Todor (DIN Software), Melinda Hodkiewicz (UWA), Gabriela Henning (Intech), Josh Ki (Lockheed), Roger Hart (NIIMBL), Adlane Rebai (Merck Millipore Sigma), Stephen Wing (Merck Millipore Sigma), Elyse Eason (Merck), Dimitris Kiritsis,
| panelIconId | 2b06 |
|---|---|
| panelIcon | :arrow_up: |
| panelIconText | ⬆️ |
| bgColor | #DEEBFF |
Presentation Upload Link - TBA
Event Photos
Tuesday, 8 April : Plenary, tutorials and working sessions (09:00 - 17:30)
Opening Plenary
(Room ???)Time | Agenda Topic | Speaker | Description | ||||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
09:00 - 09:05 | Welcome from the organizers | Serm Kulvatunyou (NIST) | Welcome and logistics info from the organizers | ||||||
09:05 - 09:10 | Welcome from the host | Joanie Chin, NIST Engineering Lab Director | |||||||
09:10 - 09:4035 | Jim Wilson (OAGi President and CEO) | Introduce OAGi and OAGi IOF/Connect memberships and their organizational missions. Updates on the organizational changes, e.g., BMIC formation. | |||||||
09:40 35 - 10:25 | Keynote 1 | Chaitan Baru (NSF) | Topic: KG & AI | ||||||
Break: 10:25 - 10:45 | |||||||||
15 | Knowledge Graph and AI | Jemin George (NSF Program Director and Army Research Laboratory) | NSF Proto-OKN Project | ||||||
10:15 - 10:45 | Ontology in Industry | Rebeca Arista (Airbus) | This talk will showcase the Execelab project at Airbus featuring the integration of design and simulation using an IOF Driven Semantic Hub. | ||||||
Break: 10:45 - 11: | 25Keynote 2 | Possibly - Melinda or a Janna Hasting | Topic: Ontology and AI 1 | 11:25 - 12:05 | Smart Standard | Possibly - Alexandru Todor | |||
Lunch: 12:05 - 13:30 | |||||||||
10 | |||||||||
11:00 - 11:30 | Ontology and AI | Nicole Manno and Douglas Orellana (ManTech) | This talk, entitled “Enhancing Accessibility to Portfolio Analyses through an Ontologically-Backed Digital Thread”, will showcase ManTech’s Smart Portfolio Solution which uses AI and an ontologically-backed digital thread architecture to allow users to access and analyze complex data across information systems. | ||||||
11:30 - 12:00 | Metadata Modeling for Enterprise Integration | Yan Lu (NIST) | The talk introduces a uniform, general, and extendable metadata model which captures and represents the most essential metadata elements for finable, accessible, interoperable and reusable manufacturing data for Industry 4.0/5.0. | ||||||
12:00 - 12:30 | Industrial Data Sharing Security | Ian Phillips (Lockheed Martin) | This talk will describe a new initiative at OAGi to fill the standard gaps that would enable a Federated Data Security. Current shortcomings in current data sharing security and the need for a new Federated Data Security scheme will be described. | ||||||
Lunch: 12:30 - 13:30 | |||||||||
Tue Breakout Sessions
Time | Breakout 1 | Breakout 2 |
|---|---|---|
13:30 - 15:30 | IOF for Digital Thread Tutorial Organizers: Dusan Sormaz and Saruda Seeharit (Ohio University) |
Presentations: Slides | Handout
Synopsis: This tutorial will walk the participants through |
an hands-on exercise to use GraphDB tools with IOF ontology constructs to capture |
and retrieve digital thread of a manufactured product in various lifecycle phases in a consistent pattern. | Enterprise Integration Governance with OAGi Connect Tutorial Organizers: Josh Ki (Lockheed Martin), Hakju Oh (NIST), Michael Figura (OAGi) |
Synopsis: This tutorial will demonstrate how Lockheed Martin has use the OAGi connectCenter tool, which has been co-developed with NIST, in enterprise integration governance. Recently released features such as the Business Information Entity (BIE) reuse and inheritance and BIE Package management will be covered. | ||
Break: 15:30 - 16:00 | ||
|---|---|---|
16:00 - 18:00 | IOF Core Tutorial Synopsis: | |
This tutorial will walk the audiences through usages of entities in the IOF Core focusing on those added/changed in recent releases such as Event, State, and Situation. | Biomanufacturing Ontology Tutorial Synopsis: |
Break: 15:00 - 15:30
15:30 - 17:30
Application Ontology Development and Deployment or Ontology Mapping Tutorial
Organizers: ???
Synopsis: ???
Material Science and Engineering (MSE) Tutorial
Organizers: Alexandru Tudor (DIN Software), Thomas Hanke (Fraunhofer), Shengyen Li (NIST)
Synopsis: The organizers will lead you through a hands-on use case on using the MSE ontology for material characterization. Time permitted, linking material characterization to process improvements such as in additive manufacturing may be introducedNIIMBL has recently donated biomanufacturing ontology to the IOF. While the ontology is still a work-in-progress, this tutorial will walk the audiences through use cases, discuss issues related to modeling and instantiations of various types of recipes. | ||
Reception | ||
|---|---|---|
For tutorials, participants are expected to have their own laptop to do hands-on exercises. Protege, Mobi, or other applications may be used depending on the instructor.
Wednesday, 9 April • 09:00 - 18:00
Time | Agenda Topic | Speaker | Description |
|---|---|---|---|
09:00 - 09: |
Keynote 4: ???
Chris Mungall (U of Eidinburg)
Topic: Data Integration for AI vs. LLM for AI
Responsible AI
Data Integration and AI??? / Yan Lu
Michael - The future of standard-based interoperability
09:40 - 10:20
Keynote 5: Metadata Modeling for Enterprise Integration
Yan Lu (NIST)
Topic: Ontology and Industry
Break: 10:20 - 10:35
10:35 - 11:15
Keynote 6: Ontology in Industry
Possibly - Christian Arieu (Sanofi)
11:15 - 11:55
Quality Ontology Update/Discussion
Alexandru Todor
11:55 - 12:35
IOF Core Update and Discussion about Shared Terms from WGs
Milos/Jim/Arko
Lunch: 12:35 - 13:30
30 | IOF Materials and Qualities Ontology Update | Thomas Hanke (Fraunhofer) Alexandru Todor (DIN Software) | This talk will provide updates about the materials and qualities ontology being worked on in the IOF Material Science and Engineering WG. |
|---|---|---|---|
09:30 - 10:00 | Smart Standards | Alexandru Todor (DIN Software) | This talk will describe the smart standard initiative which aims that setting a new standard for standard by encoding it using ontology for enhancing clarity, semantic precision, and testability. |
Break: 10:00 - 10:20 | |||
10:20 - 11:00 | Ontology in Industry | Stephen Kahman (CrownPoint Technology) | Pharmaceutical Industry Chemical, Manufacturing and Control Ontology Standard Effort |
11:00 - 11:30 | Lifecycle Assessment Ontology | Stephen Granite (CrownPoint Technology) and Ana Nikolov (NIST) | This talk will explore how ontologies can enhance life cycle analysis for biomanufacturing processes. |
11:30 - 12:00 | IOF Ontology Pattern | Arkopaul Sarkar (NIST), Jim Logan (OAGi IOF / Ontogenesis), Milos Drobnjakovic (NIST) | This talk will describe the detail of the first release of the IOF Ontology Patterns. |
12:00 - 12:30 | Data and Ontology project at NIIMBL | Roger Hart (NIIMBL) and Stephen Wing (Merck MilliporeSigma) | This talk will describe the current plan for data schema and ontology standard development driven by the needs in the biopharmaceutical manufacturing industry. |
Lunch: 12:30 - 13:30 | |||
Wed Breakout Sessions
Time | Breakout 1 | Breakout 2 | |
|---|---|---|---|
13:30 - 15:30 | Tutorial on IOF Development ProcessIOF Architecture WG Meeting Organizers: Will Sobel Synopsis: Mock up development/review/test/approval process.The IOF Architecture WG Meeting covers the changes in the IOF development process, focusing on the high-level workflow and management of ontologies in source control (GitHub). The Architecture WG made progress in defining the rules for what constitutes a domain ontology, a module, and a sub-domain ontology to inform content organization when developing ontologies and achieve consistent structure across all working groups. The meeting will also cover changes made to the annotation vocabulary, how those changes impact the development processes, and how those changes need to be incorporated into existing ontologies. The ontology community has not adequately addressed many of these issues, so the IOF is doing some green field work specifying the rules and procedures for normative ontology development. | Ontology for Additive Manufacturing (AM) Organizers: Yan Lu, Shengyen Li - NIST)Agenda, Lisha White (NIST) Synopsis: Despite its rapid interest, the use of models and simulations, which is critical in the era of digital twin (DT), remains a challenge for AM development. Currently, there is a lack of methods for characterizing digital twin models and computation technology to meet various requirements of AM decision makings. Thus, this session opens the conversation on how to potentially use ontology to achieve “fit-for-purpose” DT development and deployment for AM and start discussing notions related to modeling and simulation, and DT composition in the context of AM. | |
Break: 15:30 - 16:00 | |||
16:00 - 18:00 | AI Tools for Ontology Development Organizers: Alexandru Todor Synopsis: ??? | Ontology for Additive Manufacturing Part 2Supply Chain Ontology Tutorial Organizer: Farhad and Ali Synopsis: This session will feature hands-on exercise in utilizing the supply chain ontology for a supply chain use case. | Product Service Systems Working Group Meeting Organizers: Ana Correia (ATB Bremen) Synopsis: The session will present the PSS-Pass project (http://www.pss-pass.eu) where we are creating Digital Passports for Product Service Systems in 3 industrial pilots (in different manufacturing sectors). This session will continue to discuss terms and plans to release the first version of the product service systems ontology. Bill of Materials and related notions will be discussed. |
Banquet | |||
Thursday, 10 April, 09:00 - 18:00
• IOF Working Sessions Part 1 and OAGi Connect Part 1Time | Breakout 1 | Breakout 2 | Breakout 3 | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
09:00 - 11:00 | IOF Architecture TG Working Session Part 1
Agenda | SlidesBFO Tutorial Organizers: Barry Smith (University at Buffalo) and Jim Logan (OAGi IOF / Ontogenesis) Synopsis: The first hour will give general introduction to BFO, aimed at newcomers. The second hour will address issues that people are having with BFO. Issues will be collected in advance. | Reasoning with Machine Learning Lifecycle Ontology Organizers: Milos/Ana Synopsis: ??? | Supply Chain Working Group Meeting
| Perawit, Hakju Oh, and Ana Nicolov (NIST) Synopsis: This session will present the need and use cases for a Machine Learning Lifecycle Ontology (MLLO). Then, an overview of MLLO will be given. The audience will be walked through a hands-on tutorial on using the Machine Learning Lifecycle Explorer (MLLE) system. MLLE is a NIST-developed open-source tool for interacting with MLLO data, which aims to aid ML model understanding and reuse. Session chairs are working on an additional scenario to be included in the tutorial in order to demonstrate how MLLO may expedite ML development tasks such as feature selection. | ||
Break 11:00 - 11:20 | ||||||
11:20 - 13:00 | IOF Architecture TG Working Session Part 2
| Maintenance Ontology Tutorial or Visualizing Ontology in UML-Like Diagram with Opensource Tools Organizers: Arkopaul Sarkar and Evan Wallace (NIST) Synopsis: This session will go over a PlantUML pattern developed in the IOF for visualizing, brainstorming, and documenting OWL ontology and axioms. The audience will be guided through an exercise to use the pattern on some ontology expressions of their choice. A software tool is being develop to render OWL using the PlantUML pattern and the session may include a tutorial on such tool. | IOF Core/CCO Mapping Workshop Synopsis: This session will discuss the relationship and potential mechanical linkage between CCO and IOF Core ontologies. | Aerospace Industry Roundtable Organizers: Rebeca Arista (Airbus), Jim Logan (OAGi IOF/Ontogenesis) Synopsis: This is an invitation only session. Please contact Jim Logan if you are interested in joining. In this session, Rebeca will present her vision about IOF ontology use to support Airbus' missions. Then a discussion will be opened to participants with the objective to identify action items that lead to an aerospace industry working together to create a shared aerospace industrial ontology. | ||
Lunch 13:00 - 14:00 | (Turquoise Ballroom)||||||
14:00 - 16:00 | Core Working Group/Patterns Meeting Milos Drobnjakovic (NIST) Organizers: Arkopaul Sarkar ( ENITNIST) , Jim Logan ( Dassault Systèmes) | OAGI OAGi IOF / Ontogenesis), Milos Drobnjakovic (NIST) Synopsis: This session will showcase IOF patterns that have been developed in the IOF WG over the past year. | OAGi Connect Meeting Part 1 (Detailed Agenda) Organizers: Jim Wilson (OAGi) | and Serm Kulvatunyou (NIST) | Synopsis: OAGi Connect Meeting is a half-day program where detailed updates and working sessions related to the OAGi connectCenter tool and OAGi connectSpec standard will be conducted. Cross-cutting topics across the Connect and IOF standards and tools will also be discussed in this session. Key topics this year includes the OAGi Roadmap for Standards-based Semantics Integration, Multi-standard Management, and Mapping Data Management. | |
16:00 - 1718:00 | System Engineering Working Group Meeting | Organizers: Jim Logan ( | Dassault Systèmes)||||
17:00 - 18:00 | ||||||
OAGi Connect Meeting Part 1
Time
Agenda Item
Speakers / Moderators
Description
14:00 - 14:30
Opening and Welcoming
Jim Wilson (OAGi)
Give opening remarks. Provide OAGi Connect organizational updates, achievement milestones, and future outlook.
14:30 - 15:00
Standards-based semantic interoperability roadmap
Nenad/Serm
15:00 - 15:40
Mapping efficiency
Nenad/Elena
15:40 - 16:10
Mapping problem characterization
Elena/Serm
Break: 16:10 - 16:30
16:30 - 17:00
Multi-standard HR-Open
Metadata design pattern
17:00 - 18:00
connectCenter application to Ag
Jim
Core Ontology Working Group
Time
Agenda Item
Speakers / Moderators
Description
14:00 - 14:30
Draft formalization of material states
Arkopaul Sarkar (ENIT)
Presentation of the proposed formalization of material state and state transitions supported by a set of use case scenarios.
14:30 - 15:10
Preliminary demonstration of process model to IOF ontology correspondence
Arkopaul Sarkar (ENIT)
Milos Drobnjakovic (NIST)
Jim Logan (Dassault Systèmes)
Replicate an activity diagram with IOF ontologies and demonstrate the correspondence of the ontological representation to the activity diagram.
15:10 - 16:00
IOF Core Ontology roadmap
Brief recap of the completed and ongoing work followed by a working, interactive session that will determine the development priorities and outline the development timeline.
Ontology for Additive Manufacturing
Time
Agenda Item
Speakers / Moderators
Description
09:00 - 09:30
AM Monitoring and Control Use Case
Arko/Yan (NIST)
The objective of the session is to bring AM ontology researchers and practitioners to share their ontology development experiences and use cases and pursue collaborative opportunities to develop ontological model to advance AM technology and accelerate the use of ontology in AM industry.
09:30 - 10:00
Digital Twin Services Use Case
Lisha White (NIST)
10:00 - 10:30
AM Simulation Use Case
Shengyen Li (NIST)
10:30 - 11:00
Using ontology with Prompt Engineering in AM
Paul Witherell (NIST)
11:00 - 11:20
Break
11:20 - 11:50
Preliminary AM IOF Ontology
Arkopaul (NIST)
11:50 - 13:00
Open Discussion
Alex Kitt (EWI)
System Engineering Working Group
Time
Agenda Item
Speakers / Moderators
11:20 - 11:30
Introduction to systems engineering ontology
Jim Logan (Dassault Systèmes)
Jinzhi Lu (Beihang University)
11:35 - 11:50
The role of ontology in semantic-MBSE and its applications
Xiaochen Zheng
11:50 - 12:05
Towards a Digital Engineering Factory for Students
Joe Gregory (University of Arizona)
12:05 - 13:05
Discussion about IOF SE ontology
Jim Logan (Dassault Systèmes)
Supply Chain Working Group
OAGi IOF / Ontogenesis), Allen Chow (Boeing) Synopsis: The System Engineering WG will discuss use case and terms such as Model. |
Friday, 11 April, 09:00 - 13:00
Time | Breakout 1 | Breakout 2 |
|---|---|---|
09:00 - 11:00 | Demonstration of Airbus' System Engineering using IOF Ontology Organizers: Rebeca Arista (Airbus), Arkopaul Sakar (NIST) Synopsis: This is a demonstration of the Execelab project featuring the integration of system architecture and simulation models using an IOF ontology-driven Semantic Hub to facilitate design decisions for aircraft manufacturing using IOF ontologies. | OAGi Connect Meeting Part 2 (Detailed Agenda) Organizers: Jim Wilson (OAGi) and Serm Kulvatunyou (NIST) Synopsis: OAGi Connect Meeting is a half-day program where detailed updates and working sessions related to the OAGi connectCenter tool and OAGi connectSpec standard will be conducted. Cross-cutting topics across the Connect and IOF standards and tools will also be discussed in this session. Key topics this year includes the OAGi Roadmap for Standards-based Semantics Integration, Multi-standard Management, and Mapping Data Management. |
11:00 - 13:00 | Manufacturing Operation Management Ontology (MOMO) WG Organizers: Gabriela Henning (UNL-CONICET, Argentina), Adlane Rebai (MilliporeSigma) Synopsis: At the time of this agenda write up, a MOMO WG is being formulated among some IOF members, motivated by the NIIMBL’s contributed biomanufacturing ontology. This session will inform the audience about the motivation of the WG, WG charter, and discuss issues and findings that have been worked on over the past 6 months such as the relationship with the Production Planning and Scheduling and Product Service Systems WGs and modules. |
Detailed Session Agenda
OAGi Connect Meeting Part 1 (Thursday)
IOF Architecture Task GroupTime | Agenda Item | Speakers / Moderators |
|---|
0900 - 09:40
Introduction to CISA and IDT
Ryan Riccucci (U.S. Customs and Border Patrol)
Barry Smith (NCOR)
09:40 - 10:20
Introduction to IOF SCRO
Farhad Ameri (Arizona State University)
Break: 10:20 - 10:50
10:50 - 11:50
SCRO & IDT collaboration
Ryan Riccucci (U.S. Customs and Boarder Patrol)
Farhad Ameri (Arizona State University)
Production Planning and Scheduling Working Group
Time
Agenda Item
Speakers / Moderators
Description
16:00 - 16:30
Raytheon Use Cases
Bill Mandrick (Raytheon)
16:30 - 17:00
Dusan Sormaz (Ohio University)
Ontologizing various types of models and specifications such that their correspondence to reality as well as implicit connections are captured. Representing models and specifications - the challenges of OWL modeling with abstract entities
17:00 - 17:20
Theory of Planning
Arkopaul Sarkar (ENIT)
17:20 - 17:30
PPS WG ontology roadmap
Dusan Sormaz (Ohio University)
17:30 - 18:00
Discussion
Topics: Digital artifacts, Information Content Entities, Relationships between Record, Requirement, Specification, Order, Status, Roadmap
Notions of Requirement and Specification are already in IOF Core. There is a proposal for Record from Maintenance Working Group. Other typical information entities are Order and Status. What are relationships between these entities. Is Record just has other ICEs as part? Expected outcome is a refine roadmap for the PPS WG.
Description | |||
|---|---|---|---|
14:00 - 14:20 | Opening and Welcoming | Jim Wilson (OAGi) | Provide OAGi Connect organizational updates, achievement milestones, partnerships, and future outlook. |
14:20 - 15:10 | Standards-based Semantic Interoperability Roadmap | Nenad (Stratevia)/Serm (NIST) | This session will present a vision on data integration, and discuss the intersection of traditional standard and ontology-based standard. |
15:10 - 16:00 | connectCenter application to Ag | Brent Kemp, Ben Craker (AgGateway) | This session will talk about the progress and the needs of the AgGateway in the adoption of the connectCenter. |
Break: 16:00 - 16:20 | |||
16:20 - 17:00 | Multi-standard HR-Open/ChemE | Steffen (ADP)/Hakju (NIST) | This session will present the new connectCenter support for multi-library visualization and management and discuss future direction. |
17:00 - 18:00 | ConncectCenter, connectSpec Roadmap Discussion | Jim Wilson (OAGi) | Best practices in business context management. What are the use cases for varying standard expressions such as as genAI input, as object model for browsing |
OAGi Connect Meeting Part 2 (Friday)
Time | Agenda Topic | Speakers / Moderators | Description |
|---|---|---|---|
09:00 - |
10: |
|---|
Reasoner
Melinda Hodkiewicz (University of Western Australia)
Johan Kluwer (DNV)
Problem:
As we start to deal with industry data sets, we are going to need reasoners that can handle reasoning as data scales.
Where is the ‘parallel reasoner’?
There has been no new reasoning software of any significance for almost a decade.
Hermit was last updated in 2017 and there is limited ongoing maintenance and support.
We are not seeing any benefits from developments in IT/LLM in the reasoner space.
There have been new developments such as RDFox, and while this is welcome and does many things well, it does not derive equivalences between classes which is important to identify duplication (e.g. in industry catalogs).
Paper that substantiates some of the above.
Discussion: Is this an area that IOF-IDO-NIST-EU-KGA and others can collaborate on?
09:45 - 10:25
Evan Wallace (NIST)
Tour of the proposed IOF ontology development process and tools.
10:25 - 10:55
Evan Wallace (NIST)
Adlane Rebai (Merck MilliporeSigma)
Deprecation and moving refactoring. Introduce semantic versioning? How to use IRI subtopic? Industry Council IRI?
Break, lunch, attend other sessions: 11:00 - 16:00
16:00 - 16:30
Development, implementation, and testing tools
Stephen Kahmann (Crown Point Technologies)
Adlance Rebai (Merck MilliporeSigma)
Summary from the Toolkit working session earlier in the day and may be call for a new TG and participation.
16:30 - 17:00
Open
Evan Wallace (NIST)
Friday, 11 April, 09:00 - 13:00
Time
Breakout 1
Breakout 2
09:00 - 11:00
Manufacturing Operation Management Ontology WG (Gabriela Henning)
OAGI Connect Meeting Part 2
Jim Wilson (OAGi)
Serm Kulvatunyou (NIST)
11:00 - 13:00
MLLO WG
OAGi Connect Meeting Part 2
Time | Agenda Topic | Speakers / Moderators | Description | ||||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
09:00 - 11:30 |
| 11:30 - 12:00 | Meta-data Message Header ADAPT standard | 12:00 - 12:3000 | Flexible Supply Chain WG | Salifou/Elena | Mapping use cases and initial tooling |
10:00 - 11:00 | OAGi Data Security WG | Ian Philips (Lockheed Martin) | This session will work on a list of use cases, use case detail, and project plan for the industrial data sharing security | ||||
Break: 11:00 - 11:20 | |||||||
11:20 - 12:00 | Modernizing EDI and API for AI | International Trade Administration (ITA) | This session will feature a presentation form ITA and its industry stakeholders in their initiative to modernize EDI and API in the supply chain and logistics in enable AI | ||||
12:00 - 12:30 | Mapping Efficiency Evaluation | Elena/Nenad | Presentation about the mapping methods evaluation | ||||
12:30 - 13:00 | Wrap up | Jim Wilson (OAGi) | |||||